Azakeru (Self-Mockery)

Hirabayashi Taiko


Self-Pity, Self-Disgust, and Self-Ridicule: The Plight of the Outcast Woman in Hirabayashi Taiko’s “Self-Mockery”
rherman@middlebury.edu
“She described her life in one word – hell” (94). As the protagonist narrates the end of the play unfolding in front of her, these words “[rip] through [her] like a dagger,” and for good reason. “Self-Mockery” (1927), a short story by Japanese author Hirabayashi Taiko, centers around the life of a young woman living ... read more

“She described her life in one word – hell” (94). As the protagonist narrates the end of the play unfolding in front of her, these words “[rip] through [her] like a dagger,” and for good reason. “Self-Mockery” (1927), a short story by Japanese author Hirabayashi Taiko, centers around the life of a young woman living in misery. With a tragic backstory, a “wretched” man for a husband, and virtually no money, the protagonist Yoshiko leads a bleak life in Tokyo. Told from the first-person perspective, the reader gets an intimate view into the life of this downtrodden woman who feels “adrift in an ocean of fatigue” and “engulfed by a wasteland” (81).

The story begins with Yoshiko’s streetcar ride home. She comes from Yada’s house – a Bourgeois man who she sleeps with for money – and is heading back towards the tiny apartment she shares with her husband Koyama. Her disdain for the men in her life is perhaps only surpassed by her disdain for herself. Yoshiko routinely describes herself as ugly and strange-looking, picking at her “yellow teeth,” “saggy skin,” and stained kimono. She describes men passing her in the street, sneering and “disappointed at what they have just seen.” She even goes so far as to describe it amusing to “offend men” with her “shabbiness and ugliness” (90). Her self-disgust is only amplified by her outcast nature, as she describes herself as a “solid, grey thread” among the vivid colors of the excited Tokyoites she passes on the street (76).

With a husband who writes – then routinely fails to publish – “unsolicited manuscripts,” Yoshiko is the one who must scrounge up money for their survival, namely through her visits to Yada’s house. What is perhaps confounding about this dynamic is that her husband is the one who pushes her to coax money out of the “men [she] had sexual relationships with” (81). Despite being the technical “breadwinner” of this relationship, this dynamic does not serve to empower her in the least. Rather, money becomes her burden because Koyama “looks down on her” as a woman with “many blemishes” that has “no choice but to please her man in whatever way she can” (81). Consequently, she finds herself having to go back to Yada – a man who fills her with disgust and misery – just to get the money to eat.

“Self-Mockery” is thus a refreshingly honest piece from the perspective of a struggling proletarian woman. Yoshiko is disempowered in almost every way – she has resigned to a life of financial instability and lack of bodily autonomy. Yet, her vulnerability amidst her depressing circumstances is coupled with an inspiring resilience, the reason why this protagonist is one to root for. Though her circumstances are grim, her commentary is fresh and entertaining. This short story is a quick read, stuffed with both blunt inner dialogue and the imagery of a grimy and dusty Tokyo. Her hyper-awareness of her surroundings, humorous self-ridicule, and sharp observations contribute to her candid tone throughout the piece.

Though most are fortunate enough not to relate to Yoshiko, that does not mean her story is not worth reading. Literature can serve to expose the perspectives of those that have been cast aside from mainstream history. Hirabayashi Taiko’s writing reveals the lesser-known struggles of poor women during Japan’s early Shōwa period (1926-1989). “Self-Mockery” is honest, unique in perspective, and heavily inspired by Hirabayashi Taiko’s own struggles as a proletarian woman. This is definitely a recommended read – short, easy, and accessible, even for those with little knowledge of Japanese history and culture.

Total Votes : 0 Vote Up Edit Reply


rherman@middlebury.edu
To what extent did views surrounding sex evolve during this period? How do Yoshiko's actions and observations provide evidence of this?

nyoshida@middlebury.edu
What is the significance of Yoshiko's pregnancy? Is there a significant distinction between her first pregnancy and her second? What does the addition of her pregnancy add to Hirabayashi's commentary on the female existence and role in society?

efelix@middlebury.edu
Yoshiko represents an educated and sexually liberated woman who is part of the working class. In what ways is this similar/different to the moga of the Taisho period?

jenglish@middlebury.edu
Is there any cultural significance to the two pairs of geta being stacked on each other like that? The landlady's reproach for them was clear, but I was wondering if it signals something.

ejkim@middlebury.edu
Quote: Koyama keeps repeating his praise for "selling mourning bands" for the rest of the day. Each time I hear it I nearly suffocate and feel strangely ticklish. In bed that night I am composed enough to mutter to myself, "I've sold a mourning band." By the time I hear Koyama's heavy breathing next to me, however, I am crying, thrown into despair that I've never experienced before. My tears trickle down quietly onto the pattern of the quilt.
         I was just confused as to why the "mourning band" was repeated so much/what the purpose/significance of this phrase was. I know that Koyama mentions that this phrase "expresses our life so well," but I don't understand why she felt "ticklish." Those two "questions" popped into my head when reading the last paragraph.

xiyaoh@middlebury.edu
How do the absurdly reversed gender functions reflect Hirabayashi's attitude of the effect of the Proletarian movement?

mkemmer@middlebury.edu
In multiple instances in Self-Mockery, Yoshiko spends time critiquing her “scarred” body. What purpose do these moments serve and does Yoshiko directly associate her body’s “ugliness” as something that came about due to her contact with men?


rherman@middlebury.edu

Coutts, Angela. "Gender and Literary Production in Modern Japan: The Role of Female‐Run Journals in Promoting Writing by Women during the Interwar Years." Signs 32, no. 1 (2006): 167-95. Accessed December 10, 2020. doi:10.1086/505271.

This article recounts the emergence of leftist literary journals in Japan, highlighting their exclusion of female voices. Hirabayashi Taiko is first mentioned on page 173 as “a token female voice” in the male-dominated proletarian literary movement. The article then goes on to describe the advent of female-run proletarian literary journals, some of which published some of Hirabayashi Taiko’s most celebrated works.


rherman@middlebury.edu

Grace, Elizabeth. "Women Educating Women: Class, Feminism, and Formal Education in the Proletarian Writing of Hirabayashi Taiko and Kang Kyŏng-ae." U.S.-Japan Women's Journal, no. 48 (2015): 3-32. Accessed December 13, 2020. http://www.jstor.org/stable/26401827.

This article examines the experiences of leftist women writers in Japan and Korea during each nation’s period of modernization. Grace explains the challenges that accompanied the “gendered ideologies of modernity” to which women were expected to conform (3). Unpacking Hirabayashi Taiko’s literary choices in “Self-Mockery” and “The Schoolgirl,” Grace explains how Hirabayashi’s writing facilitated the transition from the “earlier feminism of the New Woman to the radical feminism of the proletarian woman” amidst a “turbulent political climate of Japanese patriarchal imperialism" (18).


rherman@middlebury.edu

Kusakabe, Madoka. 2011. “Sata Ineko and Hirabayashi Taiko: The Café and Jokyû as a Stage for Social Criticism.” Japanese Language & Literature 45 (2): 618–19. http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=edo&AN=77806433&site=eds-live&scope=site. 

This source analyzes Sata Ineko and Hirabayashi Taiko’s use of the “café” as sites that exposed Japan’s oppressive idea of womanhood and the “commodification and exploitation of working women under capitalism” (iv). It explores the topics of “ideal womanhood” and both Sata and Hirabayashi’s use of “corporeal experiences and sensations” in their writing of women and class-consciousness. This source also goes into detail about Hirabayashi Taiko’s involvement in the proletarian literary movement.


rherman@middlebury.edu

Ondrake, Laura Katherine. 2011. “Hirabayashi Taiko: Issues of Subjectivity in Japanese Women’s Autobiography in Fiction.” Japanese Language & Literature 45 (2): 642–43. http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=edo&AN=77806468&site=eds-live&scope=site.

This source discusses Hirabayashi Taiko’s deeply personal writing style on broader proletarian and feminist issues, saying: “not only are her works about suffering on a personal level, they are works that deal with her own personal narrative” (11). Through examining several of Hirabayashi Taiko’s essays and short stories, including that of “Self-Mockery,” “In the Charity Ward,” and “Evening Wind,” readers come to understand how Hirabayashi’s writing was often a direct expression of her own struggles in life as a proletarian woman.